Jayanagar 3rd Block East Bangalore-560011, Karnataka India
Jayanagar 3rd Block East Bangalore-560011, Karnataka India

Can a life insurance claim be rejected because the policyholder failed to disclose another existing insurance policy?
In a significant Supreme Court case, Reliance Life Insurance rejected a ₹10 lakh death claim after discovering that the deceased policyholder had not disclosed an earlier ₹11 lakh life insurance policy.
Although the Gujarat State Consumer Commission and National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) had ruled in favour of the nominee, the Supreme Court overturned those decisions on 24 April 2019.
The Court held that existing insurance coverage is material information that must be disclosed when specifically requested.
The decision highlights the importance of accurate disclosure in life insurance proposals and the consequences of concealing existing policies.
About the Case
On 10 July 2009, a policyholder purchased an ₹11 lakh life insurance policy from Max New York Life Insurance.
Two months later, on 16 September 2009, he applied for another ₹10 lakh term insurance policy with Reliance Life Insurance Company Ltd.
However, while completing the Reliance Life proposal form, he answered “No” when asked whether he already held life insurance coverage.
He also entered “Not Applicable” in the section requesting details of existing insurance policies.
Reliance Life issued the policy on 22 September 2009.
Unfortunately, the policyholder died on 8 February 2010, less than five months after the policy commenced.
His wife and nominee, Rekhaben Nareshbhai Rathod, submitted a ₹10 lakh death claim on 24 May 2011.
During its investigation, Reliance Life discovered that the deceased already held an ₹11 lakh policy with Max New York Life, under which a death claim had been settled.
On 30 August 2011, Reliance Life rejected the claim, citing non-disclosure of the existing policy.
What Was the Dispute?
The central dispute was whether failure to disclose an existing life insurance policy could justify repudiating a death claim.
Reliance Life argued that the policyholder had provided incorrect information despite being specifically asked about existing insurance coverage.
The insurer maintained that such information was necessary for assessing financial risk and determining whether additional coverage should be issued.
The nominee challenged the rejection.
The District Consumer Forum initially dismissed her complaint. However, the Gujarat State Consumer Commission overturned that decision, and the NCDRC upheld the ruling in her favour.
Reliance Life subsequently approached the Supreme Court.
The Court examined the principle of utmost good faith, which requires truthful disclosure of material information in insurance contracts.
It also considered Section 45 of the Insurance Act, 1938, as it stood at the relevant time.
Since the claim had been repudiated within two years of policy commencement, the additional statutory restrictions applicable after two years under the historical provision did not apply in the same manner.
How Was the Case Resolved?
On 24 April 2019, the Supreme Court ruled in favour of Reliance Life Insurance.
The Court held that details of existing life insurance policies were material information for evaluating a new insurance proposal.
The policyholder had been specifically asked about previous coverage but failed to disclose the earlier ₹11 lakh policy.
The Supreme Court therefore upheld the insurer's decision to repudiate the ₹10 lakh death claim.
It allowed Reliance Life's appeal and overturned the decisions of the State Consumer Commission and NCDRC.
However, the Court also considered the nominee's circumstances.
She had already withdrawn ₹16,18,987 under an earlier interim arrangement.
Exercising its powers under Article 142 of the Constitution, the Supreme Court directed that this amount should not be recovered from her.
Thus, the claim repudiation was upheld, but the amount already withdrawn remained protected.
Why This Matters
This case demonstrates that life insurance disclosure obligations extend beyond medical history.
Existing policies can also influence an insurer's assessment of financial risk.
The important lessons include:
BasketOption.insure Insights
Life insurance is intended to protect loved ones financially. However, incorrect declarations can create serious difficulties during claim settlement.
At BasketOption.insure, we recommend:
Contact us today or visit BasketOption.insure, the leading insurance brokers in Bangalore, for your policy, claims review, and expert advisory services. Visit https://basketoption.insure/ or get in touch with our experts today to explore insurance plans that truly care about your needs.
Reliance Life rejected the claim because the policyholder failed to disclose an existing ₹11 lakh life insurance policy.
Reliance Life Insurance Company Ltd. and Max New York Life Insurance.
No. A person can hold multiple life insurance policies, subject to applicable underwriting requirements.
Insurers may consider existing coverage when assessing financial risk and determining appropriate additional insurance.
The Supreme Court upheld Reliance Life's repudiation of the ₹10 lakh death claim.
The judgment was delivered on 24 April 2019.
It involves withholding information relevant to an insurer's assessment of the risk or decision to issue coverage.
Yes. The Supreme Court directed that ₹16,18,987 already withdrawn under an interim arrangement should not be recovered.
It requires parties to an insurance contract to act honestly, including disclosing material information known to the applicant.
They should disclose existing policies, review all proposal declarations and maintain accurate insurance records.